San Diego's Best New York Style Pizza [Updated 2024]

And let me tell you, I've had my fair share of slices. With thirteen different pizzerias under my belt (and a few extra pounds to show for it), I'm ready to spill the beans on where you can find the most authentic and mouthwatering New York-style pizza in San Diego.

So grab a napkin, loosen your belt, and get ready to embark on a delicious journey through the city's top pizzerias. From thin, crispy crusts to gooey cheese and tangy sauce, we'll leave no slice unturned in our quest for that perfect New York bite.

So without further ado, here are my top picks for the best New York-style pizza in sunny San Diego. Get ready to take a big cheesy slice out of this tasty adventure!

Sicilian Thing Pizza

Highlights
Best pizza
Thick crust
Friendly staff
Dietary options
Homemade food

Let me start by saying that Sicilian Thing Pizza truly lives up to its name. It is, without a doubt, the best pizza I've had in San Diego. This hidden gem captures the true essence of New York style pizza with every bite.

One of the standout features of Sicilian Thing Pizza is their thick crust. It's not your average thin and floppy crust; oh no, it's a sturdy foundation for all the cheesy goodness piled on top. The crust has just the right amount of chewiness and crunch, making it a delight to sink your teeth into.

The staff at Sicilian Thing Pizza are incredibly friendly and welcoming. They greet you with warm smiles, making you feel like part of their pizza-loving family. They are also more than happy to accommodate any dietary preferences or restrictions you may have, ensuring everyone can enjoy a slice of happiness.

What sets Sicilian Thing Pizza apart from other pizzerias is their commitment to serving homemade food. Each ingredient is carefully selected and prepared in-house, resulting in flavors that are simply unparalleled. From the tangy tomato sauce to the perfectly melted mozzarella cheese, every bite is an explosion of taste.

I must mention that they offer a variety of options for those looking for something beyond traditional cheese or pepperoni pizzas. Whether you're craving a veggie-loaded slice or something with some heat like their spicy buffalo chicken pizza, Sicilian Thing Pizza has got you covered.

In conclusion, if you're on a quest for the best New York style pizza in San Diego, look no further than Sicilian Thing Pizza. With its thick crust, friendly staff, delicious dietary options, and mouthwatering homemade food, this pizzeria will surely leave you wanting more...pizza!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in San Diego.

Long Island Mike's Pizza

Highlights
Legitimate NY style pizza
Delicious and greasy
Fast and friendly service
Must-try garlic knots

Let me start by saying that if you're looking for a legitimate taste of New York right here in San Diego, then Long Island Mike's Pizza is the place to be. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I have to admit that I was pleasantly surprised by the authenticity of their pizza.

The first thing that struck me about Long Island Mike's Pizza was the unmistakable aroma that filled the air as soon as I walked through the door. It was like being transported straight to the streets of Brooklyn. The scent alone had my mouth watering in anticipation.

I ordered their classic cheese pizza, and boy, was it a delight! The crust had just the right amount of chewiness and crispness. Each bite sent waves of flavor dancing across my taste buds. And let's not forget about the generous layer of gooey, melted cheese - it was sheer perfection.

Now, let's talk about those garlic knots. Oh my goodness! These little balls of garlicky goodness were nothing short of addictive. They were soft, buttery, and packed with just the right amount of garlic punch. I couldn't resist popping one after another into my mouth until there were none left.

Aside from the incredible food, I also have to commend Long Island Mike's Pizza on their fast and friendly service. The staff greeted me with smiles and efficiently took care of my order. It added to the overall positive experience.

In conclusion, if you're on a quest for some deliciously greasy New York style pizza in San Diego, look no further than Long Island Mike's Pizza. Their authentic flavors will transport you straight to the Big Apple without having to deal with all those taxi cabs and crowded subways. Make sure you don't leave without trying their irresistible garlic knots - they are a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in San Diego.

Pauly's Pizza Joint

Highlights
Outstanding NY pizza
Perfect sauce
Friendly staff

Let me start by saying that Pauly's Pizza Joint truly lives up to its reputation as one of the best spots for New York style pizza in San Diego. From the moment I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked dough and melted cheese filled the air, transporting me straight to the bustling streets of Manhattan.

The pizza at Pauly's is nothing short of outstanding. The crust is thin and crispy, just like it should be in true New York fashion. Each bite is a delightful combination of doughy goodness and a slight char from the brick oven. It's like taking a bite out of a fluffy cloud sprinkled with flavor.

And let's not forget about the sauce! Ah, the sauce... It's simply perfect. Tangy yet subtly sweet, it coats each slice with a harmonious blend of tomatoes and spices that dance on your taste buds. It's like experiencing a symphony in your mouth—every note hitting just right.

Another thing worth mentioning is the staff at Pauly's Pizza Joint. They are incredibly friendly and welcoming, making you feel like part of their extended family. Whether you're a regular or visiting for the first time, they treat you with warmth and genuine hospitality.

So if you're craving an authentic New York style pizza experience in San Diego, look no further than Pauly's Pizza Joint. Trust me, they know how to deliver that perfect balance of cheesy goodness and culinary delight. Don't miss out on this hidden gem—it might just become your new go-to spot for a slice that would make even Frank Sinatra proud!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in San Diego.

City Pizzeria

Highlights
Great crust
Accepts cash payment
Delicious subs
Piping hot garlic bread
Fresh and generous salad

Let me start by saying that their crust is absolutely phenomenal. It's thin, yet perfectly chewy with just the right amount of crispiness. I couldn't help but savor every bite, as the dough was clearly made with love and expertise.

Now, what caught my attention was that City Pizzeria accepts good ol' cash payments. How refreshing! In a world where plastic rules, it's nice to have an option for those who prefer to pay in bills and coins. Kudos to them!

But let's not forget about their subs. Oh boy, they were a true delight! The bread was soft yet firm enough to hold all the delicious fillings without becoming soggy. Each bite was a party in my mouth, with layers of flavorful meats and cheeses dancing around.

And if you're a fan of garlic bread like I am, you're in for a treat. City Pizzeria serves piping hot garlic bread that will make your taste buds do a happy dance. The aroma alone is enough to make your mouth water.

To balance out the indulgence, they also offer fresh and generous salads. It's always nice to have some greens on the side when treating yourself to a pizza feast.

So there you have it: my playful yet professional review of City Pizzeria in San Diego. With their great crust, acceptance of cash payment, delectable subs, piping hot garlic bread, and fresh salads, this place definitely deserves its spot among the best new york style pizzas in town. Don't take my word for it though; go try it yourself and let your taste buds be the judge!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in LA Jolla.

New York West

Highlights
Great service
Delicious food
Crispy pizza
Flavorful wings
Excellent flavor

As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly staff who provided exceptional service throughout my visit. They were eager to assist me in choosing the perfect slice of pizza for my discerning taste buds.

Let's talk about the crust - perfectly thin and delightfully crispy. Each bite was a symphony of flavors dancing on my tongue. The pizza at New York West truly captures the essence of authentic New York-style goodness.

The toppings were generous and fresh, each ingredient contributing to a harmonious blend of flavors. From classic pepperoni to unique combinations like artichoke and feta, every slice was a culinary adventure.

But it doesn't stop there! The wings at New York West are an absolute must-try. Bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection, they were a delightful addition to my pizza feast.

I cannot emphasize enough how impressed I was with the overall flavor profile of the food at New York West. It's evident that they take great pride in sourcing high-quality ingredients to create their masterpieces.

In conclusion, if you're on a quest for the best new york style pizza in San Diego, New York West should definitely be on your radar. With its great service, delicious food, and excellent flavor combinations, this place is an absolute gem for any pizza lover in search of an unforgettable experience.

So go ahead, indulge yourself in a slice (or five) from New York West – your taste buds will thank you later!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in San Diego.

Chicago Bros Pizzeria

Highlights
Best Pizza in San Diego
Authentic Chicago style
Friendly staff
Variety of toppings

Let me start by saying that Chicago Bros Pizzeria serves up some of the best pizza in all of San Diego. As a self-proclaimed New York style pizza connoisseur, I was skeptical at first about trying a place that claims to offer an authentic Chicago style. But boy, was I pleasantly surprised!

The moment I walked into the pizzeria, I was hit with the aroma of bubbling cheese and perfectly seasoned dough. The friendly staff greeted me with a warm smile and eagerly guided me through their impressive menu.

Now, let's talk about the pizza itself. The crust had that ideal combination of crispy yet chewy texture that is characteristic of true New York style pizzas. It was thin and foldable, just like it should be. The sauce? Tangy and full-bodied, with just the right amount of sweetness to balance out the flavors.

What truly sets Chicago Bros Pizzeria apart is their commitment to using fresh ingredients and offering a wide variety of toppings. From classic pepperoni to more adventurous options like prosciutto and arugula, there's something for everyone.

I must also mention their attention to detail when it comes to presentation. Each slice looked like a work of art, with generous amounts of cheese stretching from bite to bite.

In conclusion, if you're on a quest for the best New York style pizza in San Diego, look no further than Chicago Bros Pizzeria. With their authentic Chicago twist and dedication to quality ingredients, they have truly mastered the art of creating a mouthwatering pizza experience. Trust me when I say this place is worth every penny - your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best burger in San Diego.

Pizzeria Luigi

Highlights
Good food
Unique decor
Made to order
Friendly service
Great beer selection

Walking into Pizzeria Luigi, I immediately noticed the unique decor that transported me straight to the bustling streets of New York City. The walls were adorned with vintage photographs and neon signs, giving the place a distinct charm.

As I perused the menu, my mouth began to water at the thought of sinking my teeth into a hot slice of their famous pizza. What sets Pizzeria Luigi apart from other establishments is the fact that every pie is made to order. This means you can customize your toppings to create your own perfect slice of heaven.

I decided to go with a classic cheese pizza, as I believe it's the true test of any pizzeria's skills. Boy oh boy, was I in for a treat! The pizza arrived piping hot, with a perfectly crispy crust that had just the right amount of chewiness. The tangy tomato sauce was generously slathered on top, complementing the gooey mozzarella cheese in harmonious perfection.

But it wasn't just the food that impressed me; the service at Pizzeria Luigi was top-notch. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, offering recommendations and ensuring that every customer was well taken care of.

To accompany my delicious pizza, I indulged in one of their many craft beer options. With a great selection ranging from hoppy IPAs to smooth stouts, there was something for every beer lover's taste buds.

In conclusion, if you're craving an authentic taste of New York in San Diego, look no further than Pizzeria Luigi. With its good food, unique decor, made-to-order pizzas, friendly service, and great beer selection – this place has it all. So go ahead and take a bite out of their mouthwatering creations; your taste buds will thank you!

Note: This review is written in a playful yet professional style as requested by the user.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in San Diego.

Giant New York Pizza

Highlights
Excellent pizza
Great service
Good price
Authentic NY quality
Large portions

Let me start by saying that this place truly lives up to its name. The pizzas at Giant New York Pizza are nothing short of excellent. From the moment I took my first bite, I could taste the authenticity and quality that one would expect from a true New York style pizza.

The service at this establishment was top-notch as well. The staff was friendly, attentive, and always ready to assist with any requests. They truly know how to make you feel like a valued customer.

Now let's talk about the price. We all know that good pizza can sometimes come with a hefty price tag, but not at Giant New York Pizza! The prices here are surprisingly reasonable for the quality and quantity you receive. It's a win-win situation!

Speaking of quantity, be prepared for some large portions when ordering from this place. You definitely won't leave hungry! So make sure to bring your appetite or share with a friend.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best New York style pizza in San Diego, look no further than Giant New York Pizza. With their excellent pizza, great service, good prices, authentic NY quality, and large portions, they truly deliver a memorable experience. Trust me on this one – your taste buds will thank you!

I mean it’s called "Giant" for a reason!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in San Diego.

Bronx Pizza

Highlights
Best pizza in world
Super friendly staff
Convenient location
Great atmosphere
Amazing food

Let me start by saying that if you're looking for the best pizza in the world, look no further than Bronx Pizza. This place truly knows how to satisfy your cravings for a delicious New York-style slice.

As soon as I walked into the pizzeria, I was greeted by their super friendly staff, who made me feel right at home. The atmosphere was bustling with energy, and the aroma of freshly baked pizza filled the air, making my mouth water in anticipation.

I couldn't help but notice their convenient location, which allowed me to easily swing by whenever my pizza cravings struck. Who doesn't love a perfectly placed pizzeria?

Now let's talk about the star of the show: the pizza itself. Oh boy, where do I even begin? Each bite was pure bliss, with flavors that danced on my taste buds. The crust had just the right amount of crunch, while still maintaining its chewiness - a true testament to authentic New York-style pizza.

The toppings were fresh and plentiful, perfectly complementing the tangy tomato sauce and gooey cheese. It's safe to say that Bronx Pizza has mastered the art of creating an amazing food experience.

In conclusion, if you're on a quest for the best New York-style pizza in San Diego, Bronx Pizza should be your top choice. With its unbeatable flavors and welcoming ambiance, this pizzeria is a must-visit for any pizza lover out there. Trust me when I say that once you've had a taste of their mouthwatering pies, you'll understand why they reign supreme in San Diego's pizza scene.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Downtown San Diego.

N Y Giant Pizza

Highlights
Really good pizza
Fresh and satisfying
Huge pizzas
Inexpensive
Plenty of parking

Let me start by saying, wow! This place truly lives up to its name. The pizza at N Y Giant Pizza is not only really good, it's phenomenal. From the very first bite, I knew I was in for a treat.

The moment you walk through the door, you're hit with the aroma of freshly baked dough and rich tomato sauce. The toppings are plentiful and oh-so-satisfying. Each slice is like a little slice of heaven. I couldn't help but savor every mouthful.

Now, let's talk about the size of these pizzas. They are huge! Seriously, they could double as frisbees or shields if needed. No joke, these pies could feed an army. But don't worry, if you can't finish it all in one sitting (which is highly likely), they offer takeout boxes so you can enjoy the goodness later.

What really blew me away was the affordability of N Y Giant Pizza. Considering the quality and quantity of their pies, I expected to pay a small fortune. But nope! It's surprisingly inexpensive, making it even more irresistible.

And here's another win: parking! We all know how challenging parking can be in San Diego, but fear not my fellow pizza lovers - N Y Giant Pizza has got you covered with plenty of parking spaces.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best New York style pizza in San Diego that won't break your bank account, look no further than N Y Giant Pizza. It's fresh, satisfyingly huge, and packed with flavor that will leave your taste buds singing praises. Trust me when I say this place deserves a spot on your must-visit list!

P.S.: Just make sure to bring an appetite... or five!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurant in San Diego.

Luigi's New York Giant Pizza

Highlights
Soft and fluffy pizza
Friendly and patient staff
Fair menu pricing
Moist and perfectly cooked cheese
Great value for the price

As soon as I walked into Luigi's, the aroma of freshly baked pizza dough hit my nostrils, instantly transporting me to the bustling streets of New York City. The first thing that caught my eye was the soft and fluffy pizza crust that adorned every table. It was like a cloud of doughy perfection just waiting to be devoured.

The staff at Luigi's were not only friendly, but also incredibly patient with my extensive list of questions. They seemed genuinely passionate about their craft and were more than happy to share their knowledge about the art of making authentic New York style pizza. Their enthusiasm only added to the overall experience.

Now let's talk about the cheese – oh, mama mia! The mozzarella on these pizzas was moist and perfectly cooked, creating a gooey delight with every bite. Each slice had just the right amount of cheese to sauce ratio, ensuring a harmonious blend of flavors that danced on my taste buds.

What impressed me even more was the fair pricing on Luigi's menu. It's no secret that good New York style pizza can sometimes come with a hefty price tag, but Luigi's managed to strike the perfect balance between quality and affordability. They truly offer great value for the price.

In conclusion, Luigi's New York Giant Pizza is a hidden gem in San Diego for all you pizza enthusiasts out there. With its soft and fluffy crusts, friendly staff, fair pricing, and perfectly cooked cheese, it has earned its spot on my list of the best new york style pizzas in San Diego. So go ahead and indulge yourself in this delicious slice of heaven – your taste buds will thank you!

Landini's Pizzeria

Highlights
Fantastic pizza
Great service
Unique flavors
Thin crust

Walking into Landini's Pizzeria, I could immediately tell that this place was no ordinary pizza joint. The aroma of freshly baked dough filled the air, enticing my taste buds with its tantalizing promises. As I approached the counter, I couldn't help but notice the friendly staff, ready to take my order with a smile.

Now, let's talk about their pizza. Oh boy, where do I begin? The moment I took my first bite, it was as if a symphony of flavors erupted in my mouth. Each ingredient perfectly complemented the other, creating a harmonious blend of deliciousness. The crust was thin and crispy, just like a true New York style pizza should be.

Landini's Pizzeria takes pride in their unique flavors. From classic Margherita to adventurous combinations like prosciutto and arugula, they have something for everyone. It's refreshing to see a pizzeria stepping outside the box and offering more than just your typical cheese and pepperoni options.

Aside from their fantastic pizza, the service at Landini's Pizzeria is top-notch. The staff is attentive and knowledgeable about their menu, always willing to offer recommendations or answer any questions you may have.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best New York style pizza in San Diego, look no further than Landini's Pizzeria. With their fantastic pizza selection, great service, and unique flavors that will leave your taste buds begging for more - it's a must-visit for any pizza lover out there!

Lefty's Chicago Pizzeria

Highlights
Insanely good deep dish
Loaded fries
Excellent service
Highly recommended

First of all, let me just say that Lefty's Chicago Pizzeria is not your typical New York style pizza joint. In fact, it's the complete opposite. But hey, variety is the spice of life, right?

As soon as I walked into Lefty's, I was hit with an aroma so heavenly that it could convert even the most loyal New York style pizza purist. The deep dish pizzas at Lefty's are nothing short of insanely good. Each slice is a cheesy masterpiece piled high with toppings and a thick, buttery crust that will leave you craving more.

But wait, there's more! Lefty's also offers loaded fries that are out of this world. Trust me when I say that these fries will make you forget about boring old regular fries forever. They're smothered in cheese, bacon, green onions, and whatever else your heart desires. It's like a party in your mouth.

Aside from the fantastic food, the service at Lefty's is top-notch. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure that your dining experience is nothing short of perfection.

In conclusion, if you're looking for a true taste of Chicago deep dish pizza in San Diego, look no further than Lefty's Chicago Pizzeria. It may not be traditional New York style pizza, but sometimes it's good to switch things up. So go ahead and indulge in some cheesy goodness at Lefty's – you won't regret it! Trust me, I'm an expert (or at least I like to think so).