San Diego's Best NY Pizza [Updated 2024]

With countless pizza joints popping up all over town, I've taken it upon myself to try them all. After devouring 13 different slices, I'm here to share my top picks for the best ny pizza in San Diego.

Get ready to sink your teeth into cheesy goodness and experience that perfect New York fold. From thin crusts to generous toppings, I've searched high and low to find the most authentic slice in town.

So hold on to your taste buds as I take you on a lighthearted journey through San Diego's pizza scene!

New York West

Highlights
Great service
Delicious food
Crispy wings
Cooked well pizza
Friendly staff

Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately greeted by the friendly staff who were eager to assist me. Their warm welcome set a positive tone for the entire dining experience.

As I perused the menu, I couldn't help but notice the wide variety of options available. While my focus was on pizza, I couldn't resist ordering a side of their crispy wings. Let me tell you, these wings were nothing short of extraordinary. They had just the right amount of crispiness and were bursting with flavor. It was as if each bite transported me straight to Buffalo!

Now, onto the main event – the pizza. The aroma that wafted from the kitchen was irresistible, leaving me salivating in anticipation. When my order arrived, it was clear that New York West takes pride in their craft. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, with just enough chewiness to satisfy any pizza connoisseur. The toppings were generously applied and each ingredient showcased its own unique freshness.

What impressed me most about New York West was not only their delicious food but also their attention to detail when it came to cooking each pizza. Every slice had an evenly melted layer of cheese and toppings that were cooked to perfection.

The service at New York West deserves a special mention as well. The staff went above and beyond to ensure that my needs were met throughout my visit.

In conclusion, if you're searching for an authentic taste of New York City right here in San Diego, look no further than New York West. With their great service, delicious food, and crispy wings that could rival those found in Buffalo itself, this place is a true gem for any pizza lover like myself!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in San Diego.

Sicilian Thing Pizza

Highlights
Best pizza in SD
Delicious Sicilians
Friendly employees
Accommodates dietary restrictions
Great vibe and atmosphere

Let me start by saying that Sicilian Thing Pizza hands down offers the best pizza in San Diego. As a connoisseur of New York-style pizzas, I was thrilled to discover this hidden gem.

Upon entering, I was immediately greeted by their friendly employees who were more than happy to guide me through their menu. The aroma of freshly baked dough wafted through the air, teasing my taste buds and making it impossible to resist ordering a slice (or two).

Their Sicilian pizzas are an absolute delight! With each bite, I experienced a symphony of flavors. The crust had the perfect balance of crispy and chewy textures, providing a satisfying base for the rich tomato sauce and gooey cheese. Toppings were abundant and fresh; there was no skimping here!

What sets Sicilian Thing Pizza apart from its competitors is their commitment to accommodating dietary restrictions. They offer gluten-free crust options, ensuring that everyone can enjoy their mouthwatering creations.

In addition to the outstanding pizza, the atmosphere at Sicilian Thing Pizza is fantastic. The cozy interior with its rustic decor creates a welcoming ambiance that makes you feel right at home.

So if you're looking for an authentic taste of New York in San Diego, make sure to visit Sicilian Thing Pizza. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in San Diego.

Long Island Mike's Pizza

Highlights
Legitimate NY style
Greasy and crispy
Delicious
Fast and friendly
Great prices

Let me start by saying that Long Island Mike's Pizza serves the real deal, a legitimate NY style pizza that will transport you to the bustling streets of New York City. As soon as I took my first bite, I knew I was in for a treat.

The crust of their pizzas is the perfect balance between greasy and crispy. It's a delightful combination that creates a symphony of flavors in your mouth. Each slice is like a work of art, with just the right amount of cheese and toppings distributed evenly across the entire pizza.

The taste? Oh boy, it's absolutely delicious! The tangy tomato sauce combined with the melty cheese and flavorful toppings is simply divine. Every bite is an explosion of flavors that will leave you wanting more.

Not only is the pizza amazing, but the service at Long Island Mike's Pizza is top-notch. The staff is always fast and friendly, making sure you have everything you need to enjoy your meal. They are knowledgeable about their pizzas and eager to recommend their favorites.

And let's not forget about the prices! The value for money at Long Island Mike's Pizza is outstanding. You can indulge in an authentic NY style pizza without breaking the bank.

In conclusion, if you're on a quest for the best ny pizza in San Diego, make sure to stop by Long Island Mike's Pizza. Their pizzas are truly exceptional - from the crust to the toppings - providing an unforgettable culinary experience. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in San Diego.

New York New York Pizza & Pasta

Highlights
Sooo good
Exceeded expectations
Friendly staff
Great options

Let me start by saying, wow, this place is sooo good! As soon as I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked pizza hit me like a gust of flavor-filled wind. It instantly transported me to the bustling streets of New York City.

I ordered their classic cheese pizza and boy, did it exceed my expectations! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, just the way a true New York slice should be. Each bite was a harmonious blend of tangy tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella cheese. It was like a symphony playing on my taste buds.

The staff at New York New York Pizza & Pasta were incredibly friendly and welcoming. They made sure I had everything I needed and even recommended some of their other great options. They truly know how to make you feel like part of the family.

Speaking of options, this place has them in abundance! Whether you're a fan of traditional toppings or more adventurous flavors, they have something for everyone. From classic pepperoni to unique combinations like prosciutto with arugula, there's no shortage of delicious choices.

In conclusion, if you're on a quest for the best ny pizza in San Diego, look no further than New York New York Pizza & Pasta. Trust me when I say that this place will satisfy all your pizza cravings and leave you wanting more. So grab a slice (or two), enjoy the delightful atmosphere, and let your taste buds embark on an unforgettable journey to the Big Apple right here in sunny San Diego!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in LA Jolla.

N Y Giant Pizza

Highlights
Best pizza
Fresh and satisfying
Huge pizzas
Inexpensive
Plenty of parking

Let me tell you, folks, this place lives up to its name! N Y Giant Pizza truly serves up the best pizza in San Diego. From the moment I walked through the door, I could smell the delicious aroma of freshly baked dough and savory toppings.

The first bite was a revelation. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside, yet soft and chewy on the inside. It had that unmistakable New York flavor that instantly transported me to the bustling streets of Manhattan.

What sets N Y Giant Pizza apart from the rest is their commitment to using only the freshest ingredients. Every topping was bursting with flavor, from plump tomatoes to creamy mozzarella. Each bite was a symphony of taste and texture.

And let's talk about size, shall we? These pizzas are not for the faint-hearted. They are huge! I had to use both hands just to hold a slice. But don't worry about breaking the bank because N Y Giant Pizza is incredibly inexpensive, making it perfect for those times when you want to indulge without emptying your wallet.

Another thing worth mentioning is their ample parking space. We all know how frustrating it can be to find parking in San Diego, but at N Y Giant Pizza, there's no need to stress about that.

In conclusion, if you're in search of a true taste of New York right here in sunny San Diego, look no further than N Y Giant Pizza. Their pizzas are fresh, satisfyingly enormous, and won't break the bank. Trust me when I say this is an experience you don't want to miss out on!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in San Diego.

Giant New York Pizza

Highlights
Excellent service
Good price
Great quality
Large portions

From the moment I walked into Giant New York Pizza, I was greeted with excellent service. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, providing recommendations that catered to my taste buds. They even offered to customize my pizza toppings to ensure maximum satisfaction.

Now let's talk about the price – it was just right! Giant New York Pizza offers a great value for your money. You won't have to break the bank to indulge in their delicious slices of heaven. It's like finding a pot of gold at the end of a cheesy rainbow.

The quality of their pizza is truly something to behold. Each bite transported me straight to the streets of New York City, where flavor reigns supreme. The crust had that perfect balance of crispy and chewy, while the sauce and cheese melded together in harmonious perfection. Every ingredient felt fresh and carefully selected.

But be warned: their portions are no joke! When they say "Giant," they mean it. A single slice could easily feed a small village (or one very hungry pizza enthusiast). So make sure you bring your appetite or some friends to share this mammoth-sized delight.

In conclusion, Giant New York Pizza lives up to its name by delivering on all fronts – from exceptional service and affordable prices, to superb quality and generous portions. It's a hidden gem nestled in San Diego, bringing a taste of the Big Apple right to our sunny shores. So go ahead and take a bite out of this giant pizza experience – you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best burger in San Diego.

NYS Pizzeria

Highlights
Wonderful pizza
Beautiful surroundings
Extensive menu
Friendly staff

Walking into NYS Pizzeria, I couldn't help but be captivated by the beautiful surroundings. The cozy ambiance and rustic decor transported me to the streets of New York City, where pizza reigns supreme.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the pizza. Oh boy, was it wonderful! Each bite was like a little slice of heaven. The crust had just the right amount of crispiness, and the cheese was perfectly melted and gooey. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, complementing the toppings with finesse.

What impressed me even more was their extensive menu. It seemed like they had every kind of pizza imaginable, from classic Margherita to unique creations like BBQ Chicken or Buffalo Cauliflower. They catered to both traditionalists and adventurers alike.

The staff at NYS Pizzeria were not only friendly but also knowledgeable about their craft. They gladly answered my questions about different pizza styles and recommended their personal favorites.

In conclusion, NYS Pizzeria truly stands out in San Diego's pizza scene as a top contender for the best NY-style pizza. So if you're craving an authentic slice of New York City without leaving sunny California, this is the place to go. Trust me when I say your taste buds will thank you for it!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in San Diego.

N.Y. Giant Pizza

Highlights
On-time delivery
Accommodating staff
Great tasting pizza
Fairly priced
Engaging employees

From the moment I placed my order, I was impressed with their on-time delivery service. In a city where time seems to move at the speed of a sloth, it was refreshing to have my pizza arrive promptly and piping hot. Kudos to N.Y. Giant Pizza for not keeping me hangry!

The staff at N.Y. Giant Pizza were nothing short of accommodating. They answered all my questions with a smile and even made some stellar recommendations. It's always a pleasure when you encounter employees who are genuinely engaged and eager to please.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the pizza itself. Oh boy, was it great tasting! The crust had that perfect balance between chewy and crispy, just like a NY pizza should be. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, while the cheese melted into gooey perfection. Each bite transported me to the streets of Manhattan (minus the noise and traffic).

One thing that pleasantly surprised me was how reasonably priced N.Y. Giant Pizza is. In a world where everything seems to come with an inflated price tag, it's refreshing to find a place that offers quality without breaking the bank.

To top it all off, the employees at N.Y. Giant Pizza were engaging and made my visit enjoyable from start to finish. They clearly take pride in their work, which shines through in every slice they serve.

In conclusion, if you're on a quest for the best NY pizza in San Diego, look no further than N.Y. Giant Pizza. With their on-time delivery, accommodating staff, great tasting pizza, fair prices, and engaging employees, they have truly earned their spot on this list.

You might also want to check out the best brunch in San Diego.

Luigi's New York Giant Pizza

Highlights
Best pizza ever
Soft and fluffy crust
Great customer service
Fair menu pricing
Convenient location

Let me start by saying, this place serves the best pizza ever. I'm not exaggerating when I say that each bite transported me to the bustling streets of New York City.

Now, let's talk about the crust. It was soft and fluffy, with just the right amount of chewiness. It had that perfect balance between being thin enough to fold yet sturdy enough to hold all the toppings without becoming a soggy mess. It was like biting into a cloud made of dough.

The customer service at Luigi's deserves its own applause. The staff was friendly, attentive, and genuinely passionate about their pizza craft. They were more than happy to recommend their signature pies and answered all my questions with a smile.

And speaking of value for money, Luigi's menu pricing is refreshingly fair. You won't have to sell a kidney just to enjoy a slice of authentic New York-style pizza. It's an affordable indulgence that won't leave your wallet feeling as empty as a crustless pie.

Lastly, let's not forget about convenience because who wants to drive across town for a good slice? Luigi's is conveniently located in San Diego, making it easily accessible for pizza enthusiasts from all corners of the city.

In conclusion, if you're on a quest for the best ny pizza in San Diego – look no further than Luigi's New York Giant Pizza. With an unparalleled taste experience, delightful customer service, and reasonable prices, this place truly delivers on its promise. Trust me; you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Downtown San Diego.

Pizzeria Luigi

Highlights
Crispy, crunchy crust
Flavorful sauce
Made to order
Unique decor
Great beer selection

Upon entering Pizzeria Luigi, I was immediately captivated by its unique decor. The walls were adorned with vintage posters of New York City, making me feel like I had stepped into a little slice of the Big Apple right here in San Diego.

But let's not judge a pizza joint solely by its decorations; it's all about the pizza itself. And boy, did Pizzeria Luigi deliver! The first thing that caught my attention was the crispy, crunchy crust. One bite and I could tell that this dough had been lovingly crafted and baked to perfection. It had just the right amount of chewiness, providing a delightful texture that complemented the toppings beautifully.

Speaking of toppings, Pizzeria Luigi certainly knows how to make their pizzas burst with flavor. The flavorful sauce was tangy and robust, perfectly balanced with just the right amount of herbs and spices. Every bite was a symphony of tastes dancing on my taste buds.

What sets Pizzeria Luigi apart from other pizza joints in San Diego is that each pizza is made to order. This means that you can customize your pie to your heart's content. Whether you're craving classic pepperoni or feeling adventurous with anchovies and pineapple (yes, I went there), they've got you covered.

To wash down this delectable feast, Pizzeria Luigi offers a great beer selection. Nothing complements a piping hot slice of pizza quite like an ice-cold brew.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best ny pizza in San Diego, look no further than Pizzeria Luigi. With its crispy crust, flavorful sauce, made-to-order options, unique decor, and great beer selection - this place has it all! So grab a slice (or five) and let your taste buds embark on a delicious journey straight to New York City without leaving sunny San Diego.

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurant in San Diego.

Bronx Pizza

Highlights
Best pizza in SD
Friendly staff
Great atmosphere
Well priced

As soon as I walked into Bronx Pizza, I knew I had found something special. The scent of freshly baked dough wafted through the air, instantly igniting my taste buds with anticipation. The atmosphere was bustling and lively, with customers eagerly waiting for their slices of heaven.

I approached the counter and was greeted by a friendly staff member who seemed genuinely passionate about their craft. They guided me through their extensive menu, which featured an impressive array of toppings and specialty pies. From classic Margherita to innovative combinations like prosciutto and fig, there was something to satisfy every craving.

After much deliberation, I settled on a slice of their famous pepperoni pizza. The first bite transported me straight to the streets of New York City. The crust was thin and crispy, providing the perfect foundation for the generous amount of stretchy mozzarella cheese that blanketed each slice. The tangy tomato sauce danced harmoniously with the savory pepperoni, creating a symphony of flavors in my mouth.

What sets Bronx Pizza apart from the competition is not only its mouthwatering pizza but also its affordability. In a world where quality often comes at a hefty price tag, Bronx Pizza remains refreshingly accessible to all pizza lovers.

In conclusion, if you're in search of the best NY-style pizza in San Diego, look no further than Bronx Pizza. With its unbeatable combination of flavorful pizzas, friendly staff, and great atmosphere, this place is truly a gem tucked away in Southern California. Don't just take my word for it; go ahead and try it yourself!

NY Giant Pizza

Highlights
Awesome pizza
Plenty of options
Good price
Delicious
Customer loyalty

Upon entering the establishment, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizza. The atmosphere was buzzing with excitement, as patrons eagerly awaited their orders.

I couldn't help but notice the extensive selection of pizzas available at NY Giant Pizza. From classic Margherita to adventurous BBQ Chicken, there was something to suit every taste bud. It was like a playground for pizza lovers! I felt like a kid in a candy store, except the candy was replaced by mouthwatering slices of cheesy goodness.

One thing that stood out to me about NY Giant Pizza was their commitment to affordability. Despite being generous with toppings and flavor, they kept their prices reasonable. It's almost as if they have some sort of magic that allows them to create pizza that is both delicious and affordable. I applaud them for not breaking the bank while satisfying our cravings.

But let's get down to business - the taste! Oh boy, it was exceptional. Each bite was a symphony of flavors dancing on my tongue. The crust had just the right amount of crispiness, while the sauce and cheese were perfectly balanced. If pizza could win an Oscar for "Best Taste," NY Giant Pizza would be taking home multiple awards.

What struck me most during my visit was the undeniable sense of customer loyalty. Regulars flocked to NY Giant Pizza like bees to honey, eager to indulge in their favorite slices. It's no wonder why people keep coming back – this place delivers on quality and taste consistently.

In conclusion, NY Giant Pizza is a force to be reckoned with in San Diego's ny pizza scene. With its awesome selection, good prices, and loyal customers, it has truly earned its spot among the best ny pizzas in town. So go ahead and treat yourself to a slice or two – you won't be disappointed!

Landini's Pizzeria

Highlights
Fantastic pizza
Friendly staff
Unique sausage
Flavorful crust

From the moment I stepped into Landini's, I could tell this place meant business when it came to pizza. The aroma of freshly baked dough wafted through the air, immediately igniting my taste buds and setting the stage for what was about to come.

Now, let's talk about their pizza. Oh boy, where do I even begin? Each bite was a symphony of flavors that danced on my tongue. The crust had just the right amount of crunch, while still maintaining that delightful chewiness we all love in a good New York slice. It was clear that Landini's took pride in their dough-making skills.

The toppings were equally impressive. Their unique sausage was a game-changer. It had a subtle hint of fennel that elevated the flavor profile to new heights. Who knew sausage could be so fancy? The quality of ingredients used was evident and truly made a difference in every bite.

But it wasn't just the pizza itself that stood out at Landini's; their friendly staff made the experience even more enjoyable. They greeted me with smiles as warm as their wood-fired ovens and were more than happy to answer any questions I had about their menu or process.

In conclusion, Landini's Pizzeria is a true gem when it comes to finding authentic New York-style pizza in San Diego. With their fantastic pizza, flavorful crust, and sausage fit for royalty, this place definitely deserves its spot on the list of best ny pizzas in town.

So if you're craving a slice that will transport you straight to the streets of Brooklyn, don't hesitate to pay Landini's Pizzeria a visit. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!